06/03/2026
I think pictures from this era are interesting because we know we are looking at masters with great reputations. However, they are often in a finished position that is different from what many people consider to be ideal in the current day "state of the art" Tai Chi practice. For example, the back leg being locked out straight at the knee, and the front knee being forward of the toes are both considered serious faults in most Tai Chi practice today. These details are closer to Shaolin wushu, and point back to the long fist origins of Tai Chi practice, but even most Shaolin practitioners today don't have the front knee exceeding the toes. The front hand is also a little different from the most common position I have seen in Part The Wild Horse's Mane, which is more of a "palm up" position - but I recognize that many people still do express the movement with the hands as shown here. I don't consider that hand position a fault; just a difference in variation or preference. THAT'S something I find very interesting: the existence of so many differing variations of movements that appear to be at odds with each other, but still land within Tai Chi principles, making them correct but different in small ways. Sometimes, these small differences may reflect technique applications a teacher or lineage may have favored, or might even be adaptations due to injury or discomfort for an influential practitioner somewhere earlier in the lineage. Always very interesting to see these. Great reminder to keep an open mind and look for principles rather than dogmatic adherence to details.
Li Yulin, 1888-1965, well known master of Yang and Sun styles of Tai Chi Chuan, as well as other Martial Arts and various weapons: