08/08/2022
I have been tutoring for the last few years and have also gotten requests to teach ASL from new learners. My background in Deaf culture has dictated to me that this is not acceptable to most in the Deaf community because, from their perspective, this should be reserved to native signers (Deaf or C/SODA). However, many students I have tutored who have taken ASL courses taught by Deaf teachers have complained to me that they are not doing well in their course because they don't understand their teacher. So, for this reason I have concluded that the best person to teach a hearing person ASL is a person who is hearing and fluent in English.
Here's my touchstone - if you were to ask a Deaf person, "who's the best person to teach their Deaf child English"? I would venture to guess their answer would be - a Deaf teacher. Why? Because they are fluent in ASL. Right? Wrong?