09/20/2013
My 4-5 grade group compared poems. We read "The Eagle" by Tennyson, "A Tragic Story" by Thackeray, and "The Tale of Custard the Dragon" by Nash, in that order. Everyone liked Ogden Nash'es poem the best. They read each poem aloud without knowing the title. The first poem was tricky for them, but after discussion about the imagery, they agreed it must be about a bird, maybe an eagle. The second poem became obvious by the end, but they enjoyed acting out the protagonist's antics. The third poem was their favorite. Each student had different reasons as to why it was the favorite. One liked that it was about a dragon, one liked that it was make-believe, one liked the nonsense words and wanted to write nonsense words in his poem, and one liked that it was an interesting story. We picked out metaphors, similes, personifications, onomatopeias, and hyperbole. Their vocabulary words were azure, sage, yore, stout, and tack. They wrote their own poems following the mood of the poems studied and read them aloud. Some had trouble with telling a story while rhyming.