08/04/2025
Cynthia Erivo as Jesus, in Jesus Christ Superstar ... 🤔🧐
Let me start by saying that I am a fan of Cynthia Erivo. I neither care that she is black, nor that she is indeed female. Jesus Christ Superstar is a challenging, controversial show — it was meant to be — from the moment it premiered on Broadway, through the release of the movie version, and subsequent productions.
Cynthia was wonderful in the movie Harriet (about Harriet Tubman). The tune that she composed for that movie — Stand Up — and subsequently sang, was brilliant, especially her live performance of it at the 2020 Oscars. I don't like everything she does, but she does have a magnificent voice, and she slayed with that tune.
That being said ... while I do NOT DISlike Cynthia as Jesus, neither do I like her.
Confession ... I'm a HUGE fan of Jesus Christ Superstar. I recall singing it with a girlfriend, countless times in her bedroom when I was in high school. Years later, I was cast in the rock opera in Vegas, and I loved every minute of it!
However, I believe that the 1973 movie with Ted Neeley as Jesus, and Carl Anderson as Judas, is THE quintessential version of the opera. Whereas Cynthia Erivo sings the part, Ted Neeley IS Jesus.
Adam Lambert does a good job as Judas, but again, I prefer Carl Anderson.
Perhaps it's because I grew up with the show, and I am biased. But I can't listen to ANY production, not even one that features someone as good as Cynthia Erivo — whom I admire — and refrain from comparing it to the 1973 film.
I've posted Ted Neeley's version of Gethsemane in the comments, so that you can make your own comparison.
www.CarolenaMatus.com
Cynthia Erivo stuns in this powerful performance of “Gethsemane” from Andrew Lloyd Webber’s legendary rock opera Jesus Christ Superstar. Taking on the role o...