11/22/2025
🌑 Why I Struggle with the Celebration of Thanksgiving:
Every year, when November comes around, I feel uneasy, and my stomach tightens.
While so many people here in the US prepare for a holiday built on gratitude, family, and abundance, I feel a deeper grief, something older than me, carried in the collective unconscious, our nervous systems, carried in the land itself.
And the older I get, the more I understand why.
I struggle with celebrating Thanksgiving because underneath the cheerful rituals is a truth that has been erased, sanitized, and mythologized.
A truth rooted in displacement, genocide, and trauma.
And this year in particular, that truth is louder than ever.
🔍 Did You Know That The Trail of Tears Happened in the Same Season We Celebrate Thanksgiving and Christmas?
🪶 The Cherokee Trail of Tears officially began in October 1838, the very season we now associate with cozy sweaters, pumpkin pie, and gratitude.
While families today gather around their tables celebrating a "shared harvest", Cherokee families in 1838 were:
• being rounded up at gunpoint
• forced into stockades
• stripped of home, community, and sovereignty
• marched over 800–1,000 miles (or more) in freezing rain, mud, and early winter storms
• watching their children and elders die from exposure, hunger, and disease
By December 1838, thousands of Cherokee were walking through snow and ice toward an unknown future in what is now Oklahoma.
The season when America celebrates gratitude, family, and abundance is the same season the Cherokee people experienced one of their most traumatizing moments.
And no matter how anyone tries to "dress it up" with a Thanksgiving turkey and pumpkin pie, there is a darker truth many of us feel.
🧬 Trauma Echoes Across Time, And It’s Happening Again
Part of why this hits me so deeply right now is because we’re witnessing a terrifyingly familiar pattern today.
In the United States right now, immigrants, including children, are being:
• rounded up
• detained in overcrowded facilities
• deported without transparency
• separated from family
• sent to places we aren’t even told about
• facing real dangers of trafficking, abuse, and disappearance
And we are invited to celebrate and pretend it’s not happening.
History doesn’t repeat itself because we don’t know it.
It repeats because we refuse to acknowledge and feel it.
And Thanksgiving in its sanitized, mythologized form is part of that refusal.
Why this matters to me:
Because we are disgracing the memory of the people who walked before us.
Because injustice leaves an imprint in the collective nervous system.
Because when I see people being displaced, hidden, and harmed, I don’t just see the present, I feel the past.
And I refuse to call it “Thanksgiving.”
🌱 What I Choose Instead
Instead of participating in a holiday built on a myth, I am now choosing something else:
• Ancestral truth-telling
• Grief that is honest instead of hidden
• Healing the collective wound of stolen land and stolen people
• Putting my time and energy toward justice and healing, not denial
And if you feel called to honor this season differently, here are Native-led and immigrant-rights organizations doing meaningful work:
🪶 Native-Led Organizations:
• NDN Collective, Indigenous-led movement for land defense, justice, and liberation
• Native American Rights Fund (NARF), Legal defense of tribal sovereignty and treaty rights
• Cherokee Nation Foundation / Cherokee Family Research Center, Education, community support, and cultural preservation
• Indian Country Today (ICT), Indigenous journalism amplifying truth and lived experience
🌍 Immigrant Protection and Justice:
• RAICES, Legal and humanitarian assistance for detained immigrants
• ACLU Immigrants’ Rights Project, Advocacy and impact litigation
• The Young Center for Immigrant Children’s Rights, Protecting unaccompanied immigrant youth
• Al Otro Lado, a Human rights organization supporting asylum seekers and migrants at the border
Supporting and advocating for organizations like these feels more aligned with the truth of this season than spending hundreds on a meal rooted in myth.
🕊️ A Final Word
Celebrate Thanksgiving in a way that feels true for you and your family. Having deep gratitude for all we have and gathering with family and friends is important.
But if something in you aches this time of year, if something feels off, if sorrow, anger, or heaviness rises, you’re not imagining it.
Some of us feel the ancestral memory of trauma in our bodies.
Some of us are here to break the silence.
Some of us are here to tell our truth.
And this is mine:
I can no longer celebrate a holiday born from the harm of humans.
But I can choose remembrance and collective healing.
And this year, I’ll be spending the day with friends, not in the traditional sense, but in a way that honors remembrance for the people whose history still echoes through this season.
Sending love to all impacted by the past and present atrocities 🙏🏻
- Brenna Haskins O’Brien
Image: AI-generated artistic rendition created with assistance from ChatGPT, inspired by historical accounts of the Cherokee removal during the Trail of Tears.