08/29/2026
A letter arrives saying Social Security paid you too much — sometimes years ago, usually through no fault of yours. Left alone, it can now quietly take half of every check.
WHAT CHANGED
For retirement, survivors, and disability benefits, Social Security's default clawback rate for new overpayment notices (dated April 25, 2025 or later) is 50% of your monthly benefit. In just over a year the rate went from 10%, to 100%, and back down to 50%.
WHY THIS IS SO UNFAIR
Overpayments are frequently the agency's own error — a delayed update, a miscalculated benefit. But the law still requires SSA to try to recover the money, and the burden lands on the person who did nothing wrong.
THE PART THAT CATCHES PEOPLE
There's a clock. Do nothing and withholding starts after 90 days. But you can ask for reconsideration (SSA-561), a waiver if it wasn't your fault or you can't afford repayment (SSA-632), or a lower monthly rate (SSA-634). Filing quickly — within 30 days — generally pauses collection while they review.
WHAT TO DO
Don't ignore the letter. Call 1-800-772-1213 or visit ssa.gov and ask about a waiver or lower rate. If the overpayment is $2,000 or less and wasn't your fault, there's a simpler waiver process.
Educational information. Sources: SSA Emergency Message EM-25029; AARP; 2026. Not legal advice.
Have you or someone you know ever gotten one of these overpayment letters — and how did it turn out?