05/18/2016
Last night a lesson with a ten-year-old reminded me students will surprise the teacher by how they demonstrate improvement. The below student has been fun to work with, and she continues to demonstrate an ear for the tune, but she naturally relies on her memory to tell her the correct notes, instead of reading the music on the page. If you've played an instrument before, you know this is a paradox: It is wonderful to play from memory, but what if you haven't actually learned your music yet?
Mr. B
Okay, Katrina, show me how things are coming with page 23...
KATRINA (plays the correct pitches, but pauses frequently to look at her hands)
Mr. B
I can tell you're struggling, Katrina, but I think it's just because you haven' been practicing enough...
Mom
We haven't gotten much practice time in this week...
Mr. B
Okay, well, we will get in some good practice time in our lesson. I want you to try it again, Katrina. This time, show me you are listening for phrases, not just playing notes. In fact, can you point to where the first phrase begins?...
KATRINA (pointing right on-target)
Mr. B
Good. And that ends...where?
KATRINA (pointing right on-target)
Mr. B
Very good. Would you play it for me again?
KATRINA (playing with improvement, though still pausing at inappropriate moments)
Mr. B
Okay, Katrina, that's better. Do you realize you've improved a lot even during the lesson today? You see, that shows me you will improve quickly if you put in practice time next week. Mom, can we talk over any kind of difficulty you've observed in Katrina's practicing? Do you have any questions?
MOM
She just needs to practice more, and...