09/01/2026
Here's what happens: five readers means five opinions, and when they contradict each other, your student is the one left untangling it. "My aunt liked the ending, but my piano teacher said cut it" is not useful information.
Instead:
✅ Pick 1-2 readers you actually trust
✅ Be specific about what you want them looking at (voice? clarity? does it sound like them?)
✅ Skip the vague "just read this and tell me what you think"
Vague requests get vague, conflicting feedback. Specific requests get answers you can actually use.
This video does a great job at demonstrating why too much feedback isn't always a good thing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpKp2x43o1M&t=4s
Who's your student's go-to reader right now?