09/20/2026
Before we have children, we often imagine them as versions of ourselves, albeit improved and corrected, but still recognizably us.
Most of what we call "family values" is the assumption that our children will inherit our identity along with our genes.
In his remarkable book Far From the Tree, author and psychologist Andrew Solomon, calls the traits we inherit and share with our parents "vertical identities." They include sexual orientation, ethnicity, language and religion.
A "horizontal identity" is different. It's a trait that shows up in a child with no precedent in the family: deafness, dwarfism, genius, autism, being gay when your parents are straight.
Nobody teaches parents how to raise a horizontally identified child, because no parent anticipates these differences.
But what happens when the most basic facts of your child's experience are outside the realm of your own experience and existence?
Often, our discomfort with our child's difference leads us to search for a fix, and it's here that the line between an identity and an illness gets drawn.
Andrew Solomon wonders aloud in Far From the Tree whether our search to correct children who aren't broken is more damaging than accepting them for who and how they are.
I wrote about this idea, my parents attempt to fix what they considered broken about me, and this book for the How to Live Newsletter.
The link to the full piece is here: https://bit.ly/4xwZrQT