10/07/2021
Mark Twain Nominee Countdown
Every year the Missouri Association of School Librarians nominate 12 middle grade fiction books for the Mark Twain Award. Every Monday (ahem or Thursday if I get too busy) for the next 12 weeks I'll post a review of those books from my 12th to 1st favorite. This week we are at 10 - Memory Keeper
I love a good action movie. There is a time and place to suspend belief and just enjoy nonstop action without really thinking it could happen. But my favorite movies are when the action movie has a twist at the end. That's why movies like Inception are some of my favorites.
When I first started the Memory Keeper, I wondered if it would have a twist in it. The author was dropping clues for one. I knew where the story looked to be heading and I was hopeful the author would pull my expectations from under me and surprise me. But it didn't.
I've talked before about how I value a book's ability to be memorable when I evaluate books. Will I remember this book in a year? Two? Five? When I think of books with a mystery, will this one be one I remember details about? That's where I felt this book fell short.
The book is well-written and paced. It has action and mystery, mean girl drama and a dash of romance. And while the author does a good job with all of these, I don't feel like any of them stands out as particularly memorable.
Lulu has the incredible ability to remember all the details in her daily life. She knows what she ate for lunch 3 months ago. This can at times be a curse but as her Gram's memory begins to deteriorate, and put her and her younger brother in danger, it turns into a blessing.
While Gram is forgetting important details, like where they parked, she is remembering secrets long ago buried. When Lulu shares them with her friends they begin to believe that perhaps Gram is more than she appears. Is Lulu's grandmother a Russian spy? If not, why does she meet with a man who acts like one?
This is a fun and engaging tale. The unique aspect of Lulu's memory make it easy to believe that these three friend will be able to unravel this mystery. When I read this book, I very much enjoyed it. But, unlike its namesake, there is very little in this book that makes it lasting in my memory.