07/20/2020
An Open Letter to the Staff of Carlisle Community School District:
Good Afternoon,
It is no secret that we have a big School Board meeting this evening. I just wanted to touch base with you all briefly about my own decision-making process with the final Return to Learn Plan to be presented and voted on tonight (or at least as “final” as something can be these days…). I have three children in the district, a wife who teaches in the district, and I know many of you personally—and those of you I do not know personally, I already have a tremendous amount of respect and appreciation for what you do and what your occupation and calling will soon be asking you to do. My own family and I have many of the same feelings of fear, apprehension, and confusion that many of you and your families are experiencing and I feel that as someone who was elected to represent our students, staff, and community, I owe it to you to reach out. Nothing angers me more as an individual than having someone in a position of leadership going silent when it seems like words and action are needed the most.
I want to commend our administrators, staff, and those involved in the multitude of committees and focus groups that have met to troubleshoot creatively in an attempt to make our return as safe and efficient as possible. This is a tough, tough time—for everyone. I have had numerous “off-the-record” conversations, read and considered several emails, have seen many different social media posts, and laughed at or was angered by different memes floating around, etc., etc.—from all sides of the topics. Just like you, I have my own personal opinions about masks vs. no masks, return to school vs. remote learning, and especially, the politicizing of all the above. My goal during this process is to remove as much of my own personal opinions as possible and focus on what we have control over. Basically, there are three main areas that I, as an individual Board Member, am trying to focus on: what the State mandates, what the CDC recommends, and the information about what our parents and staff desire gained in the survey. I will not speak on behalf of the other members of the Board or our administrators, but I suspect their processes are probably pretty similar.
First, as you know, the Governor has mandated that Iowa schools must conduct at least half of their instruction in-person when classes resume. Is it the right decision to send students and staff back to school when COVID-19 cases are spiking and many openings may be rolled back soon? I will be brutally honest and say, “I. Do. Not. Know”. I have NO idea whether this is the right decision or not, all I know is that our district is required to do so. That said, as a Board Member, instead of focusing on whether I believe our Governor’s decision is the right one or not, I am trying to help focus on possible solutions to a situation we otherwise have no control over. It appears that our administrators are taking the same approach. I am very happy we are able to offer the choice of remote learning to help students and families who choose to stay home, but I know that doesn’t always help out the staff we are calling on to teach, clean, drive, and serve in person. With the requirement to return to school comes so many questions and concerns—questions and concerns from you, questions and concerns from parents, questions and concerns from students, and questions and concerns from me. I have already asked several of the questions that you and I have and will continue to do so. Some of those questions are regarding you as staff and how certain situations will be handled. I am hopeful for some more clarity soon.
Second, our district has chosen to rely on the expertise and guidance provided primarily by the Warren County CDC. Our district will try to be as consistent as possible with the other districts in our county, but since each district is unique, being flexible will not be out of the question. We have no choice but to follow the guidance of those who specialize in the field of communicable diseases. Knowledge has been gained and suggestions have changed very regularly and the experts are doing the best they can with a new and relatively unknown threat. I am going to go out on a limb and say there will be more changes before it comes time for the doors of our schools to reopen. Without going into too much repetitive detail, currently, the recommendation is to wear masks when unable to socially distance. Per the CDC, it is also considered a close contact when an individual is within six feet of another individual for longer than 15 minutes. Do I believe the virus will hold off until that precise 15-minute mark? I can’t really say, but those are the recommendations provided to us by the experts in their field. As difficult as it is to accept, there is much I do not know about communicable diseases and will trust those in their field as I would hope others would trust me and the expertise of my coworkers to fight a house fire or cut someone from a mangled car.
Finally, I appreciate the action of Mr. Amos in providing the survey and I appreciate your participation in it. The results have greatly aided me in deciding if I would vote in favor of our current plan or not. For example, in situations where 85% of those taking the survey felt a certain way about a particular topic, it helped me in my justification for that aspect of the plan. Unfortunately, that means 15% of you may have felt differently about the very same topic. I want to apologize in advance. We are in a very polarizing situation where it is impossible to find a solution that is 100% agreeable—no matter how justified and passionate someone may be. Please know that the impossibility to appease everyone is not lost on me and that I have had some sleepless nights recapping your thoughts and feelings on different matters. I believe, whole-heartedly, that everyone involved is trying the best they can for the greatest number of people possible.
On one final note, because of my career as a firefighter/paramedic, I have been working on the frontlines of this pandemic from day one. There were many times—for lack of a better phrase—that we, as a department, were caught with our pants down in many early situations. As a result, our standard operating procedures and EMS protocols sometimes changed several times daily. We continue to figure out what works but we also continue to be slapped in the face with finding out what doesn’t work. I have the exact same fears that have been expressed to me regarding getting sick and/or bringing a sickness home to loved ones. It is also not lost on me that some of us will be sending our children into an unknown and potentially dangerous environment. This is the most difficult aspect of this entire situation for me. Bottom line—this all sucks. But we adjust on the fly as needed, and I have to again be honest in saying that parts of this plan will probably need adjusted along the way and our district will also need to adjust on the fly. Is that comforting? Absolutely not—but it is reality. What I hope is comforting is that there are some very intelligent and hardworking people involved who want nothing more than the safety of our district’s students, staff, and community while a return to in-person learning is mandated.
You are appreciated, you are respected, you are brave, and you are great at what you do. I cannot thank you enough for what you have done, what you do, and what you will continue to do for the numerous minds, hearts, and souls that learn in our district. Times are tough but we are tougher.
Thank you,
Jeramie