02/12/2016
Why teachers can’t deliver real personalized learning in today's schools.
In a traditional classroom, students do not learn unless the teacher is in control by managing and guiding the learning experience, giving students directions, and making sure they all stay on task and on pace. Because of this reality, a decision to stop and address the emotional needs of one student inevitably means temporarily neglecting the academic needs of the class. Sometimes, sending a student to a school counselor or administrator is a way to minimize this tradeoff. But when the student is gone from class, she misses valuable instructional time and falls behind. And in an education system based on whole-group instruction, teachers’ work grows exponentially when they have to catch individual students up. More generally, when many students are already behind academically and where such crises in their personal lives are far too common, focusing on social and emotional needs can quickly undermine teachers’ and administrators’ efforts to close achievement gaps and change the ultimate life trajectories of their students
The reality is that our traditional education system was designed to utilize teachers as lesson planners, graders, and managers of whole-group instruction, but today we also expect them to be counsellors, mentors, and individual learning specialists. It is unreasonable to give teachers these additional roles without changing the structure of their work. But too often we just stack teachers up with additional responsibilities and then expect them to be able to juggle everything with superhuman deftness. To solve this problem of human capacity constraints, what we need are new models of schooling that use online learning to both personalize learning to each student's’ individual needs and also free up teachers from some aspects of their work so that they can focus more on the academic, social, and emotional needs of their individual students.
It's impossible for a teacher to personalize for a student without having a clear picture of who that student is on a broad scale. One of the challenges for a classroom teacher is to capture the data--both quantitative and anecdotal--about the "profile" of student and then do something meaningful with it. It doesn't matter how big a repository of content may be; it still takes a person--a teacher who cares--to look at the student, where s/he is, what s/he needs, and where s/he's going to help find the perfect path.
As our education system has noticeably begun failing our students, many people have put the blame squarely on teachers. On both state and national levels, the Government has begun blaming teachers by holding them accountable to unreasonable testing and grade metrics despite the fact that there are numerous other problems that exist. The pressure of maintaining these ridiculous standards have led many teachers and school districts across the country to illegitimately pass students along from one grade to the next.
We must stop blaming teachers for our failing education system. They aren’t the only ones to blame and they shouldn’t be the central focus of blame. Here’s three reasons why teachers can’t deliver real personalized learning in today’s schools
Is It the Teachers Fault?
I think blaming teachers is extremely unfair. They are part of a bureaucracy with no real control over what to teach and how to teach. Teachers don't control curricula, standards or testing. They have to make do with whatever materials, worksheets and curricula they are given, even if they believe that they are ineffective. They have to prepare students for tests that often don't effectively test student ability. The belief that teachers are responsible for educational failure has lead to ideas like merit pay and compensation based on student performance.
I read an article about math teaching a few years back and one teacher's comment really stood out. The teacher said that the way he's required to teach math, it's almost impossible for students to learn. A second grade teacher called into a radio show I was listening to and said that because of state standards she wasn't able to spend enough time introducing fractions. As a result, she said many students went into third grade without adequate preparation to learn more advanced material. The teacher knew her students were going into the next grade unprepared to learn but her hands were tied in dealing with it. Teachers are often ineffective because they are forced to work with ineffective curricula, textbooks and worksheets, not because they lack teaching ability or knowledge.
Problem of Education system
The K-12 public education system is a big business, and anyone who’s worked for a big business knows that the worker bees are constantly the ones to blame, even though it’s the executives that are responsible for making the decisions that determine success or failure. The worker bees are merely doing what they’re told. In the education system, teachers are the worker bees, and it is just as absurd to blame them for the failure of our education system as it is to blame employees for the failure of a business. The fault lies at the top where the decisions that truly make the biggest impact are being made. This includes decisions that affect budgets, technological investments, etc.
Problem of society
I’m increasingly becoming convinced that our society doesn’t value education, intellect or higher thinking. The educational system as a whole can be blamed for this as well. As a society we’ve decided and accepted a school system that houses children in factory facilities 8 hours a day where they’re each stamped out like clones, one after another they are each thrown into the world with the same attributes. Each new student no better or different than the next. What our school system and our society needs to push is individualism. We can not continue building clones anymore!
The failure of our education system can’t be blamed on one group of individuals. The blame must be placed on all of us. If we each do our part to make things better, then and only then will our education system improve.
22/11/2016
04/11/2016
03/11/2016