02/10/2024
Nanotoxicology: From Past Lights and Shadows to Current Concerns
The term nanotoxicology has only gained interest from the last two decades onwards . Since that time, many advances have been made in this area. Two important factors led to a rapid progress in this branch of science . Firstly, “the large-scale production of diversified nanomaterials and remarkable progress in the development of new types of nanomaterials with disconcerting physical and chemical characteristics” . Second, many studies based on constantly improving NMs have stimulated research in Physics, Chemistry, and Bioengineering, leading to new interdisciplinary progress in Nanoscience and its applications. For example, there has been huge progress in the bioapplication of Nanomaterials(NMs)
Nanomedicine and nanotoxicology are strictly linked, since both can explore the same mechanisms and affect identical metabolic pathways . Bearing in mind that newly NMs can exhibit specific toxicity, it is necessary to summarize and reassess the data accumulated from time to time, thereby ensuring safety . The development of current nanotoxicology studies is surprising, mainly in the biological area . For example, the biosynthesis of insecticidal nanoparticles mediated by plants and other botanical products is constantly developed .
Nanotoxicology has become a subdiscipline at the interface of toxicology and NMs . Due to their extremely small size and large surface area to volume ratio, NMs have different properties compared to their larger equivalents that may enable unpredictable interactions with cells and tissues. Nanotoxicology tends to highlight the possible toxic interactions between NMs and different biological systems (cells, tissues, and living organisms). Several years of research have showed that the interactions of NMs with the environment and with cells of living organisms are highly complex . However, it has not been revealed how the properties (both physicochemical and morphological) of NMs can influence these interactions .
The morphological and physicochemical properties of NMs have a great impact on the interaction with biological cells and may influence their toxicity. Nanotoxicology is responsible for the analysis of the toxic effects of NMs, especially since the materials’ size plays a significant role in the toxicity of NMs . The concept of nanotoxicology is based on different parameters, such as the size, surface area, morphology, composition, surface chemistry, agglomeration/aggregation phenomena, etc. In fact, all of these parameters have a critical impact on the determination of the nanoparticles’ dose and consequently, the precise assessment of their toxicity. However, determining the maximum exposure values of toxic NMs would be impossible without in vitro and in vivo tests. Many strategies to study the nanotoxicology and the interaction of NMs with biological systems are already in place . Initial studies on the toxicity of NMs were carried out in the last decade of the 20th century, already revealing that materials of a micrometric scale did not present toxicity, while materials at a nanometric scale might have some toxic effect .
Toxicity Tests
Toxicity tests can be performed on cell cultures (in vitro) and in living organisms (in vivo) such as fish, mice, or rats. There are several standardized toxicological tests that are available to assess the biological response of a chemical substance. However, there is no standardization for the assessment of nanoparticles toxicity. It causes many difficulties in the comparison of the results regarding the toxicity of the tested ingredients. Most of the toxicity tests for NMs have been performed in vitro, using cultures of mammalian cells that were extracted from the most different parts of the body (e.g.,: brain, lungs, heart, skin and liver). Although in vitro tests are less expensive than in vivo and the results may be obtained in a shorter time, it is not possible to infer potential implications related with the human health based on the in vitro only .
Since continental and marine waters would be the main receiving compartment, in vivo tests were mainly carried out in aquatic organisms that would reflect the impact of nanomaterials on the environment. During the contact with animals, the variation of the NMs concentration allows to calculate statistically the indicators that will allow the comparison of toxicity between different nanomaterials and/or between nanomaterials and traditional chemical substances. The most used evaluation parameters are the LC50 (i.e., concentration of nanomaterial that causes the death of 50% of the population, LOEC (i.e., low concentration that causes a noticeable effect on the organism), and NOEC (i.e., maximum concentration, at which no effect is observed on the organisms). Moreover, experimental animal trials have advantages, with one of the important ones being the assessment of the kinetics of nanoparticles through absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion (ADME).