30/09/2024
BBC News this morning trailed the Panorama programme ‘The Menopause Industry Uncovered’ which is on this evening at 8pm.
It is already on iPlayer. I have watched it. Twice.
I don’t work for Newson Health and have never been a patient. However, whilst I agree that menowashing is a ‘thing’ - and not a great 'thing'. I’m really confused, and a bit disappointed, as to why the BBC have chosen to show the Newson clinic in such a negative light.
The BBC’s argument was around a handful of women who came forward accusing the clinic of over prescribing estrogen. These women may have legitimate concerns but out of the 45,000 women the Newson Health clinic have seen in the past 4 years is this a representative balanced view?
I personally use double the amount of body identical estrogen gel recommended by NICE (I have had a hysterectomy so do not need to counter with progesterone) my recent bloods showed my estrogen levels are average. This suggests I am a low absorber. As a non-healthcare professional it's not rocket science to understand that we all absorb gels through our skin differently!
1 in 5 women are thought to be low absorbers. However, the NICE guidelines (FIRST published in November 2015 - yes only 9 years ago – what happened before that?) recommend quite a low dose, I guess to be safe.
I believe many NHS healthcare professionals use the Newson Health’s ‘Confidence in the menopause’ course as a CPD learning tool - possibly because as of 2021 a survey showed that 33/46 medical schools in the UK only 59% had mandatory menopause medical training on the curriculum.
Is that why 45,000 women have attended the Newson Health Clinic since 2020?
Maybe the real reason we have this conflict of information and a bit of ‘us and them’ between the NHS/NICE and private clinics/celebrity endorsements is because we lack research into women’s health due to gender bias, historical exclusion, lack of awareness, or perhaps because most reproductive science research only focuses on women at the peak of their childbearing years.
So.
Are the BBC menobashing? Scaremongering? Will this set back women’s views on the menopause and HRT yet again??
And look at the dreadful picture the BBC have used of Dr. Louise Newson – that is definitely NOT the smiley image the BBC usually use! Why? 🤔