26/01/2022
Can a person with Type 2 Diabetes drink diet fizzy drinks?
Yes.
If you are currently drinking "normal" fizzy drinks, say Coke, Fanta etc and weight loss is your goal, then absolutely, you can make the swap to the zero calorie versions to maintain your fat loss goals.
Effectively by cutting out the calories in your drinks you can lose weight. Some people drink upwards of 5 soft or hot drinks per day and on average they can be up to 200 calories per drink.
Ergo, cut them out or swap to zero calorie drinks, save some calories for more food, or lose weight. Simple maths.
But there are some caveats:-
Water is always better.
You don't HAVE to drink them.
Watch your gut health, too much can cause gut distress. >10 cans per day.
children, pregnant women, nursing mothers, and those prone to seizures, headaches or migraines should limit or avoid.
So why all the negativity that we see about these drinks and in particular the artificial sweeteners?
Quite rightly there is scepticism about something "artificial". The alternative health market, which in itself is a huge industry, doesn't think that "artificial" anything has a place in our nutrition and have spent the past 30 or so years spreading confusion and myths about these products, with little or no science to back up the claims. Influencers and authors still continually write and talk about the subject, spreading fear, uncertainty and doubt about them, not realising that the chemical breakdown of a blueberry has a list far longer than sweeteners do.
Artificial sweeteners have been around a long time, about 150 years and there are many versions, some of which have an elaborate and complicated past. The fact that they have been around so long also means we have many hundred clinical studies on the damage they may cause and also the damage they don't cause.
Obviously the media like to cycle these stories, frequently writing about some of these studies and in particular linking them to diabetes and obesity.
"Fat people drink diet coke, so obviously that means they make you fat" - Daily Mail style observational comment!!
The most controversial nowadays is aspartame, used in Coca-Diet Coca-Cola and other such products. It is studies conducted on Aspartame that causes most of the attention. There was a study in 2005 on rats, which showed that by drinking these sweeteners their insulin levels rocketed and they then over ate at their next meal and stored fat.
Basically rats that drunk the drinks had chronic weight gain.
And it was this study that fuelled the recent cynicism. What they didn't share was the levels of aspartame was huge (