12/08/2026
My mind-blowing moment over professionals being afraid to ask about domestic abuse became rage as I read about the tragic case of Matilda Davis - mum of two children who died by su***de in 2022.
On the day she died, Matilda was seen by social workers. She was clearly distressed, talked about feeling like a failure and said she didn’t know what she was going to do BUT nobody asked directly about su***de.
The coroner later concluded that opportunities had been missed, and a Prevention of Future Deaths report followed. The social workers involved said they hadn’t “done the training” to be able to have that conversation.
Oh My Days!
My previous post describes how mental health workers didn’t routinely ask about domestic abuse, described uncertainty about what to do if somebody disclosed, discomfort about “delving deeper” and fear of making things worse, so different professionals, different systems, but such a similar gap. They knew the conversations mattered, but were not equipped to have them.
We cannot keep relying on professionals in situations where they may encounter domestic abuse or suicidal crisis and assume that knowing they should ask is the same as knowing HOW to ask.
Professional curiosity requires capability, it deserves more than a briefing document or ‘toolkit’ (read 20 page pdf), it requires confidence and self-belief. It deserves your time.
When we see distress, do we ask about abuse? When we see abuse, do we ask about su***de? When somebody presents with alcohol use, anxiety, housing problems, relationship breakdown, financial difficulty, parenting pressures or simply appears unable to cope, do we deal with the presenting issue and stop there, or have we equipped people to get curious about what might be sitting underneath it?
Matilda’s story is complex, and I am deliberately not going beyond what has been publicly reported about the circumstances of her life and death, but one thing I will definitely say - we cannot wait for somebody to use exactly the right words before we ask the questions that matter, and we must make sure professionals are capable of asking and responding to those questions.
“I didn’t know how to ask.”
“I was worried about making things worse.”
“I didn’t know what to do if they said yes.”
These are not failures of character. They are signs that we are expecting people to have some of the most difficult and potentially life-saving conversations they will ever have without making sure they have the language, confidence, practice and skills to do it.
Awareness is not enough.
Policies telling people to ask are not enough.
Being aware is not enough.
We need to get comfortable with the uncomfortable, especially in jobs where lives are at risk.
To Matilda’s family - I’m so very sorry for your loss 💔
*Guardian, Josh Halliday