26/09/2026
First years đ did anyone catch the new Sense and Sensibility this weekend?
Georgia Oakleyâs film (she made Blue Jean) opened on Friday, with Daisy Edgar-Jones as Elinor and EsmĂŠ Creed-Miles as Marianne. The early reviews keep returning to two things: the damp, dewy, weather-soaked look of it, and how firmly Diana Reidâs screenplay puts the sisters at the centre. Several critics have called the ElinorâMarianne bond the filmâs real love story. Austen would probably agree, given the title is a portrait of two sisters.
Then thereâs the elephant in the drawing room. Ang Leeâs 1995 version, written by Emma Thompson (who won the Oscar for it) and starring her as Elinor opposite Kate Winslet, is for many people simply what Sense and Sensibility looks like. Hugh Grant stammering through his proposal. Thompsonâs sob when Edward finally explains himself. Hard acts to follow.
So what did you make of it? đ
đ Is Edgar-Jonesâs quieter, steelier Elinor closer to Austenâs than Thompsonâs?
đ° Austenâs second chapter is John and F***y Dashwood talking themselves out of helping his stepmother and half-sisters, one shrinking sum at a time. How does the film handle money?
đ§ď¸ Frank Dillaneâs Willoughby: dangerous enough to fall for?
đŹ Does an adaptation owe more to the novel or to the famous adaptation that came before it?
Tell us in the comments. Bonus points if you read the novel first. Then bring your opinions to seminar, because adaptation is going to come up more than once this year.