Cyril Lemieux, que publicou em 2000 "Mauvaise presse : Une sociologie compréhensive du travail journalistique et de ses critique", produziu artigo crítico sobre o conceito de campo. "The twilight of fields: Limitations of a concept or disappearance of a historical reality?" foi editado no Journal of Classic Sociology. Está aqui: http://jcs.sagepub.com/content/14/4/382.
(O acesso à íntegra é restrito a pagantes, mas se você estiver em uma conexão de universidade é provavelmente de graça.)
The twilight of fields: Limitations of a concept or disappearance of a historical reality? The concept of field forged by Pierre Bourdieu is often regarded as if it could be applied universally (as the concept of ‘habitus’, for example, can be). This article shows that such an extensive use comes from a misunderstanding of the real nature of this concept. From Bourdieu’s own viewpoint, cl…