21/06/2017
My 7th Visit to Bangladesh
Education in the Slums
Post 6: Debate with stakeholders
The room was packed with the parents, slum community leader, several key individuals of the camp, some of the invited teachers, and our Partner NGO. The words were already out and the concern of the community of high that DoPeace was thinking about changing the rules of engagement. The concern was valid. I was on the front line ready to make my argument.
It was not antagonistic, as we have developed some trust in the community over the last two years. We are serving over 1200 children in that community. A civic dialog was brewing, and I was there to defend my position.
As each one was introduced, they also started to put their questions out front. Are you now going to charge tuition for the services? Other schools provide not only free education, but they also provide uniforms and food. We are here because we can’t afford to go to proper schools, and this is convenient. We cannot find schools as they have very limited enrollment. Do you understand that we are poor people and we struggle to make our ends meet? We appreciate what you are doing, but you are now disengaging yourself from us. Why can’t you continue the way it is going, as we are very happy the way it is?
I listened to them intently, trying very hard what they are really saying. I collected the questions in my mind, nodding all the time they are responding intermittently just to clarify their questions. The community leader, with whom I have quite close relationship, tried to intervene occasionally to blunt of sugarcoat the points being made, but I gently asked him to backoff. My NGOs were sitting over next to me and wondering what is going to happen.
This is not the first time, I had engaged the slum community in civic dialog. I did it twice this week, before I ended up with this community.
I started talking to them, and there was a pin drop silence.
My Board of Directors (I used much simpler language and not the lingo) wants to know if the community really wants to educate their children?
A silly question, perhaps. Of course, they want their children to get educated. Why else they are there?
My Board of Directors wants the proof, I emphasized. I pointed out that there were three nonprofit organizations before, some of them quite flush with money. They had schools in the community, and they are all long gone. So, eventually, we will go away as well.
They looked at me, bewildered. Why would you go away and betray us, like others?
Let me tell you a simple reason, I said. If I am dead today, this enterprise is going end. But there could be other reasons.
They were aghast and there were sympathetic murmurs in the room. We want a long-life for you, someone said loudly, and there were resounding agreement.
I laughed. I do not have any plans to die that quickly, I said, but I am trying to make a point, as anything can happen and it is a risky position to depend o me or any other organization 100%.
You have to be a partner in this endeavor and make sure that the schools continue in perpetuity, I said. You are solely responsible to educate your children, and for the last 40 years you have not taken any steps whatsoever, I was a little dramatic. You have been walking around these neighborhoods for years, you see the children on the streets, and you never got together to seriously plan for their education on your own.
But we do not have any money for that, said one women.
In this community of 15,000 people, I am sure that many of them can contribute one Taka per month towards the community fund for education, I replied. Have any of you contributed one Taka in the last 40 years for education? I raised my voice a little, looking at the leader and the two businessmen sitting there. There was silence.
That shows that you have no concerns about educating your children, and I cannot provide any proof to my Board of Directors to continue helping you, I was a little combative.
I want you to be engaged and stop asking for free stuff. I want partnership. I want joint venture. I kept going.
I saw them getting my point. I saw some of them relenting.