27/11/2021
When we threaten children to behave/comply, what is actually happening?
Kidsâ brains are underdeveloped. When theyâre struggling, particularly with something youâve asked of them, they often donât have the words to say âCan you help me?â or âI donât know howâ. They say this with their behaviour.
Yet, often we are expecting them to oblige or comply because we said so, or at this time of year, because otherwise Santa wonât bring them a present, a fun holiday event will be cancelled, the Elf on the Shelf is watching, or theyâll go on the naughty list.
The thing is, using these threats do not give a child the tools that they need to do better. And sometimes weâre expecting change that their age and stage of brain development suggests isnât possible.
The threats do not do anything for a child but break down their connection and trust with the adult who has these expectations, and make them feel bad about themselves for not meeting them, when they literally canât. It teaches kids that they are loved and accepted based on their outward behaviour, and that the way they behave is dictated by the rewards they receive.
Of course, a âwell-behavedâ child would make the festive season much easier for us, especially when weâre often under a lot of stress ourselves. However, as adults, we're the ones with the mature brains capable of emotional regulation and problem-solving (even though we wonât be able to do this 100% of the time), not our toddlers; not even our teenagers.
I understand that a simple reminder that the Elf of the Shelf is watching can quickly make a child âbehaveâ.
But remember that a child who has been threatened and looks âwell-behavedâ on the outside, is likely still feeling stressed on the inside, and is trying to keep it together for the sake of pleasing others, and for the sake of Christmas. We talk about behaviour as if it were a choice - but oftentimes, it isnât.
Youâre not a bad parent if you use these threats. This is just some information based on what we now know about child development that you might like to consider.
What can you do instead? Itâs the same as any other time of year. Remember that all behaviour is communication. Empathise. Connect before you correct. Reframe attention-seeking to connection-seeking. Co-regulate. Iâve covered this in many previous posts and on my blog. And yes, you can still use Elf on the Shelf without the behaviour patrol aspect!
Also, donât forget, youâre not going to get it right 100% of the time - no one can. Doing what you can with the resources you have is enough.