16/03/2019
Short Vowels e and i: elephant /ě/ or Ed / ě / contrasted with igloo /ĭ/ or itch / ĭ /.
In my book, Schuler Phonics: Primer, following the sequence of introduction of the short vowel sounds from Anna Gillingham’s Phonic Word Cards: Remedial Training for Children with Specific Disability in Reading, Spelling, and Penmanship (“The Jewel Box”), the short a and short i are the first of the two short vowel sounds introduced. Short e is the last of the short vowel sounds introduced.
That sequence has proven, as far as I’m concerned, to be valid and effective. In all my teaching and tutoring over the years, except when in Pennsylvania, whether preschool age children through adult teachers, the two short sounds of elephant /ě/ or Ed / ě / and igloo /ĭ/ or itch / ĭ /, pronounced alone and especially when contrasted with each other, have always caused the most difficulty.
Short i, when contrasted with short a, is fairly easy to teach. The problem of hearing and saying the sound of short i only arises once short e is introduced; those two sounds are very similar.
Discussing and demonstrating mouth positions for each sound helps some. Practicing HEARING the difference between the sounds is of much more value: With all five vowel letters (a, e, i, o, and u), spread out randomly on a flat surface, reordering them periodically, say the different sounds, one at a time, randomly, and have your student touch the sound heard, only saying the key word first, then once mastered, saying both the key word and the sound.
Contrast the short e and short i by first saying one, then next the other, mixing those two with the other short vowel sounds (a, o, u). I, also, recommend repeating a sound, whether correctly identified or missed, two times, even three times in a row; students seem to believe that a teacher just couldn’t be saying the exact same sound again but must be saying one of the other four. That technique forces the student to listen very, very carefully!
Mary M. Schuler
6389 South Tall Pines Road
Coeur d’Alene, ID 83814-7043
(208) 664-6253
[email protected]
p.s. The short sound of u vs. the short sound of o can, also, be confused, at times. There, I just teach the student, when pronouncing the short o sound, to form the mouth and throat into a ball and elongate the sound. In contrast, the short u sound is clipped, cut off, almost as soon as it is pronounced.
p.s.s. Sometimes, not very often, I’ve found students who confuse a and e. Again, teach the student, when pronouncing the short a sound, to form the mouth and throat into a ball and elongate the sound. In contrast, the short e sound is clipped, cut off, almost as soon as it is said.