12/09/2025
THOMAS LUDWELL LEE TO RICHARD HENRY LEE, DECEMBER 9, 1775.
“Williamsburg, Virginia. Dear Sir...The naval force of the enemy in this country consists of two sloops of war, the Otter, & Kingfisher, of sixteen six & four pounders, with their compliment of men indeed, one hundred & ten, but these much dispersed in tenders, & all except ten in the Kingfisher, & a few in the Otter, pressed men, disaffected to the cause, & unwilling to fight. Six deserters from the Kingfisher, examined last night, confirm these circumstances, which we were informed of before from other hands.
A frigate of thirty guns, with metal proportionable, by coming into Norfolk [Elizabeth] river would not only become master of these, but of Dunmore’s ship William. & a vast many other vessels loaded with the floating property of Tories, & seized cargoes, to the amount, as is said upon good grounds, of £14000. These gentry would, by such a stroke as this, be all taken up in a nett. Ld. Dunmore's preparations be all torn up by the roots, & the plan of hostility for this country to be begun anew. Ld. Dunmore has issued his first Virginia Gazette printed I think on board the William. It contains his proclamation, the oath tendered to the people of Princess Anne & Norfolk, his conquest over the militia, & the letters of the Delegates intercepted by Capt. Wallace.
PINKNEY’S VIRGINIA GAZETTE, DECEMBER 13, 1775.
“Williamsburg, Virginia. A few days ago 6 of lord Dunmore's men deserted from the Otter. They met some of our men, on their way to this city, by whom they were treated with the utmost hospitality; in return, they assisted us, with the highest pleasure, in stowing away our baggage, and in expediting our troops to their destined place. When they were asked what induced them to leave [Lord] Dunmore, they answered, "Hungry bellies, naked backs, and no fuel; besides, in other respects, the most cruel and inhuman treatment.”
COLONEL ROBERT HOWE TO THE VIRGINIA CONVENTION, DECEMBER 13, 1775.
“Norfolk, Virginia. We have scouting parties down the Bay, to give intelligence of the arrival of any vessels, or any other event, either to our advantage or otherwise. From the officers commanding those parties, we have received certain intelligence that a man of war, either of thirty-six or forty guns, is within the [Chesapeake] Bay, and on her way to this place, with a large brig, supposed to be a store ship, both full of men...”
LETTER FROM A MIDSHIPMAN ABOARD HMS OTTER, DECEMBER 15, 1775.
“Off Norfolk, Elizabeth River, Virginia. The Rebels having now nothing to obstruct their passage, arrived and took possession of Norfolk, and in the evening saluted us with a volley of small arms; on which, the next morning, I was sent on shore to their Commander, to inform him, that if another shot was fired at the Otter, they must expect the town to be knocked about their ears [ie. bombarded].”
Editor’s Note: Lord Dunmore’s Virginia Gazette was printed using a press seized by Royal Navy sailors and marines in October 1775 from the print shop of John Hunter Holt.
Thomas Lee (1730-1778) was a planter, and politician who served in the House of Burgesses and later the Virginia Senate. He was born at Stratford Hall in Westmoreland County but later lived in Stafford where he owned hundreds of acres and many slaves. Lee married Mary Aylett in the 1750s and she bore six children. After the Virginia General Assembly became bicameral, Lee was elected to the Virginia Senate to represent the Northern Neck of Virginia. On October 14, 1776, he was appointed to a committee to revise, amend, or repeal any Virginia law, subject to the approval of the Virginia House of Delegates. Unlike his brothers, Lee refused to enter into national politics. George Wythe, once said that Lee was “the delight of the eyes of every Virginian, but would not engage in public life.”
Robert Howe (1732-1786) was a Continental Army general from North Carolina during the Revolutionary War. He also played a role in the government of North Carolina, serving in the legislature. Howe, as the senior officer, engaged in negotiations over access to supplies with the captains of British ships anchored off Norfolk. The situation deteriorated, and Norfolk was burned on January 1, 1776, in an action started by the Royal Navy and completed by Patriot forces. Howe ordered most of the buildings that remained razed before he withdrew, to render the location useless to the British. During Howe's time in command, Woodford described him as a "brave, prudent & spirited commander." On December 22, 1775, Howe was thanked by the Virginia Convention.
The poor treatment of the sailors aboard HMS Otter and other Royal Navy vessels was not uncommon in the 18th century. However, the Otter’s boatswain, Tobias Verdin was an especially brutish character. He was questioned about the theft of an anchor in Portsmouth, England in 1773. After “behaving in a tyrannical manner to the Ship’s Company,” and often being “Insolent to the Officers, as well as neglecting his duty,” Verdin was suspended from duty. However, after good behavior, he was restored to duty in February 1776 by Captain Matthew Squire. However, it could be that Squire simply needed all hands on deck as desertions and deaths from disease continued unabated. At least nine seamen aboard the Otter are known to have died from 1775 to 1776. In addition to desertions and captures, this would have left the Otter undermanned. Indeed, Thomas Lee wrote in his letter above that the Otter was partially composed of “…pressed men, disaffected to the cause, & unwilling to fight.”
The midshipman who wrote these letters for publication was possibly John Buchanan who later served as a prize master of the schooner Sandwich from Norfolk, Virginia.
Images: B. Henry Latrobe, “View of Norfolk from Smith’s Point, Virginia,” 1797. Benson J. Lossing, “General Robert Howe,” 1852. Daniel Tandy, “British Man of War and Small Craft Off a Coast,” circa1800. Unknown Artist, “Midshipman,” circa 1800. Pierre Eugene Du Simitiere, “Map of the Maritime Parts of Virginia exhibiting the Sea of War and of Lord Dunmore’s Depredations in that Colony,” 1776. Norfolk, Elizabeth River, and Williamsburg are marked in red.