08/27/2026
The vast majority of parents who homeschool their children don’t abuse them. But for those who are intent on inflicting harm, homeschooling provides a highly effective guise. Child abuse and neglect are crimes of isolation; when children are kept home, they are far more difficult for social workers to interview away from the influence of their caregivers and far fewer people are able to lay eyes on them.
In every state, even in the midst of an ongoing CPS investigation, parents or guardians can withdraw their child from school to homeschool them. In 48 states, a parent can do this even if they’ve been convicted of a crime against a child. Once they are homeschooling their child, there is no requirement that the child receive regular wellness checks.
To date, the Coalition for Responsible Home Education has logged 500 cases of abuse and 200 fatalities among the homeschool population. Among the fatality cases, half involved children who were recently pulled out of school.
In the past year, cases like these have increasingly made national news. In February, first responders were called to a house fire in Connecticut. Inside, they found a man in his early 30s who weighed 68 pounds. He told police officers he had been confined at home since the fourth grade, when his stepmother pulled him from public school. Before that, his teachers had called DCF at least 20 times to report signs of abuse and starvation. In May, a similar case made headlines in New Jersey: An 18-year-old girl ran away from home and a neighbor brought her to the hospital. She later told police she had been trapped at home and subject to physical and sexual assault since the sixth grade, when she was withdrawn into homeschooling.
Revisit Amelia Schonbek’s 2025 report on the legal loophole that allows children to be pulled from school during an open CPS investigation: https://nymag.visitlink.me/Jr4pfk