10/11/2026
October 11th marks the anniversary of the destruction of the original Sand Key Lighthouse as well as the lighthouse at Key West. In early October of 1846 a hurricane formed in the Caribbean, striking Cuba on October 10th, before heading north and striking Sand Key the morning of the 11th.
There were six people at Sand Key at the time of landfall, Keeper Joshua Appleby, his daughter Eliza Patterson, her husband Thomas, and their three-year-old son. In addition, a friend of the Patterson’s, Ann Petty Harris and her adopted daughter were also visiting.
According to an article in the Joliet Signal (IL), ‘Sand Key light-house is gone—totally disappeared with buildings connected with it. The occupants, too, have perished.’ The Guardian (London) went on to say that ‘Sand Key has almost disappeared.’
The storm went on to strike Key West. Numerous people joined head keeper Barbara Mabrity taking refuge in the Key West Lighthouse, at that time located at the Southernmost Point. The Joliet Signal reports that, ‘The Key West light-house and dwelling attached are entirely gone. [T]he spot where they stood is covered by a white sand beach. Fourteen souls perished in these buildings.’
The articles also report that, ‘The light ship in the N.W. Passage dragged her moorings and went to sea, but she was recovered and returned to her position.’
After what became known as the Great Havana Hurricane struck, the lightship LV Honey stationed at Sand Key from 1846 until 1853. The construction of the present light tower was overseen by Lt. George Meade, and first lit on July 20, 1853.
The Key West Lighthouse was replaced by a temporary beacon until it could be rebuilt on its new, present day, location. The new Lighthouse was completed on January 15, 1848, with Mrs. Mabrity, who miraculously survived the storm, returning as head keeper.
A light ship continued to mark the Northwest Passage until an iron pile cottage lighthouse was completed in 1855.