The Batters Box Bake Shop

08/30/2026

Stop by today!

08/28/2026

Come on over Sunday and stock up on some sweets! Planning to have an array of cookies, brownies, and cinnamon buns!

08/24/2026

⚾️ BIG NEWS! 🧁

Muether Baking is now
THE BATTERS BOX BAKE SHOP! ⚾️✨

Same homemade treats you know and love, with a fresh new name and a little baseball flair! 🤍

🍂 NOW TAKING FALL ORDERS! 🍂

From custom sugar cookies to delicious treats for parties, school events, sports, birthdays & all of your fall celebrations — we’re ready to make your occasion a little sweeter!

📅 Fall dates are now open!
Availability is limited, so be sure to get your orders in early.

⚾️ The Batters Box Bake Shop
Step up to something sweet! 🧁

FallBaking FallTreats HomeBakery CustomSugarCookies LongIslandBakery

07/27/2026

Happy birthday Blake Muether I love you!!! I am so incredibly proud of you and so lucky to be your Mom!

07/04/2026

Happy 4th!

07/02/2026

06/24/2026

Sometimes the simplest cakes are the most beautiful

06/20/2026

This team was in a league of their own. They worked so hard and really played their hearts out! So proud of Blake and all the Larkfield Little League Honey Badgers 🥎

06/05/2026

The most beautiful bridal set 👰‍♀️🤵‍♂️

05/15/2026

When your friends kids start turning 16 😭😭😭