16/04/2026
Paper oil
AN interesting (دلچسپ) thing (چیز) is happening (ہو رہی ہے) in the oil markets (تیل کی منڈیوں) that has not received (حاصل کی) enough (کافی) media attention (میڈیا توجہ). Given (مدنظر رکھتے ہوئے) the prolonged (طویل) closure (بندش) of the Strait of Hormuz (آبنائے ہرمز) and the severe (شدید) supply-side crisis (رسد کا بحران) that has hit (متاثر کیا) global (عالمی) oil markets, there should by now have been a spiralling (تیزی سے بڑھتی ہوئی) rise (اضافہ) in the price (قیمت) of oil. But instead (اس کے بجائے), we see it rise slightly (تھوڑا سا) above $100 and then drop (گرنا) below. Sometimes (کبھی کبھار) this follows (پیروی کرتا ہے) the headlines (سرخیاں). But overall (مجموعی طور پر), a mystery (معمہ) is developing (بن رہا ہے) around why oil prices are not seeing massive (بہت زیادہ) rises these days, even as more and more countries announce (اعلان کرتے ہیں) releases (اجراء) from their strategic (حکمت عملی سے متعلق) petroleum reserves (تیل کے ذخائر) (SPR), which is a sure sign (واضح علامت) that physical shortages (حقیقی کمی) of oil are landing (پیش آ رہی ہیں) around the world.
One answer (جواب) doing the rounds (گردش میں) among oil analysts (ماہرین) is the idea (خیال) of ‘paper oil’. The argument (دلیل) is that the US Treasury (امریکی خزانہ) is actively (فعال طور پر) manipulating (ہیرا پھیری کرنا) the price of oil by selling (بیچنا) massive quantities (بڑی مقدار) in the futures market (مستقبل کی منڈی). This helps (مدد کرتا ہے) keep (برقرار رکھنا) the price of oil down (کم) in the present (موجودہ وقت). A Reuters story (خبر) published (شائع ہوئی) on March 5, the first week (پہلا ہفتہ) of the war, kicked off (شروع کیں) rumours (افواہیں) that this might be happening. “The US Treasury Department (محکمہ خزانہ) is expected (توقع ہے) to announce measures (اقدامات) as soon as Thursday aimed at (نشانہ بناتے ہوئے) combating (مقابلہ کرنا) rising (بڑھتی ہوئی) energy prices (توانائی کی قیمتیں), including (بشمول) potential (ممکنہ) action involving (شامل کرتے ہوئے) the oil futures market”, read (لکھا تھا) the opening sentence (ابتدائی جملہ) of the story, quoting (حوالہ دیتے ہوئے) a senior (سینئر) White House official (اہلکار). Brent (برینٹ) had jumped (اچھل گیا تھا) to $85 at the time, and the IRGC (ایرانی پاسداران انقلاب) had announced the closure of the Strait of Hormuz just three days earlier. To comprehend (سمجھنے کے لیے) how this works, it is necessary (ضروری) to understand (سمجھنا) a couple of things about how oil markets function (کام کرتے ہیں).
First (پہلا), there is not a single price in oil markets. There are various (مختلف) benchmark (معیاری) prices of crude (خام) oil, like Brent, Dubai Light or West Texas Intermediate (ویسٹ ٹیکساس انٹرمیڈیٹ). These refer (اشارہ کرتے ہیں) to the price of crude oil in a specific (مخصوص) market. WTI is mostly (زیادہ تر) for the Americas (امریکہ), Brent for Europe (یورپ) and Dubai Light for Asia (ایشیا). Next up (اگلا مرحلہ) are oil products (تیل کی مصنوعات) like petrol (پٹرول), diesel (ڈیزل) and jet fuel (جہاز کا ایندھن) that have their own (اپنی) prices. And then, there are petroleum products (تیل کی مصنوعات) like naphtha (نیفتھا) or LPG (ایل پی جی) that have separate (علیحدہ) prices too. Finally (آخر میں), there are what are called (کہلاتے ہیں) ‘futures markets’, where you can buy (خرید سکتے ہیں) oil today (آج) for delivery (فراہمی) at a future date (مستقبل کی تاریخ).
Under normal conditions (عام حالات میں), all these prices will move (چلیں گے) closely (قریب قریب) with each other since (کیونکہ) they are tied (جڑے ہوئے ہیں). When the price of crude rises, the price of petrol and diesel will rise more or less correspondingly (اسی کے مطابق). The cap (حد) on these is the futures price. If crude oil for delivery in June 2026 is available (دستیاب ہے) for a particular (خاص) price, the present-day (موجودہ) price will not go too far above that.
Oil watchers (مشاہدہ کرنے والے) are now wondering aloud (کھل کر سوچ رہے ہیں) whether active (فعال) oil market manipulation (ہیرا پھیری) has begun (شروع ہو گئی ہے).
What the Reuters story was trying (کوشش کر رہی تھی) to say was that someone in the administration (انتظامیہ) figured out (سمجھ لیا) that one way (ایک طریقہ) to manipulate oil prices, and keep them down (کم رکھنا) in the short term (قلیل مدت) while the war lasted (چلتی رہی), was for the US government to become (بن جائے) a massive seller (بڑا فروخت کنندہ) of oil in the futures market at a lower price (کم قیمت) than what the market is generating (پیدا کر رہی ہے). By that time (اس وقت تک) the settlement date (ادائیگی کی تاریخ) of the contract (معاہدہ) arrives (آتی ہے), the outcome (نتیجہ) of the war would be known (معلوم ہو چکا ہوگا) and they would be betting (شرط لگا رہے ہوں گے) that the US would have prevailed (کامیاب ہو چکا ہوگا), and the price of oil would have either stabilised (مستحکم ہو گیا ہوگا) or dropped. Either way (ہر صورت), it would be one way to stabilise (مستحکم کرنا) the market at a higher price point (بلند سطح), while buying (خریدتے ہوئے) some time in which to see the war through (ختم ہونے تک دیکھنا).
But things did not work out (کام نہیں کیا) as planned (منصوبہ بندی کے مطابق), obviously (واضح طور پر). The war dragged on (طویل ہو گئی). The strait (آبنائے) remained (رہی) closed (بند). And as Donald Trump (ڈونلڈ ٹرمپ) grew desperate (بے چین) to avoid (بچنے کے لیے) a catastrophe (تباہی) in the oil market, by late March (مارچ کے آخر تک) his administration had issued (جاری کیے) sanctions waivers (پابندیوں میں نرمی) for Russian oil (روسی تیل) as well as (اسی طرح) some Iranian oil. A little earlier (کچھ پہلے), they had announced releases from their SPR, usually (عام طور پر) something done when the country has been attacked (حملہ کیا گیا ہو).
Those steps (اقدامات), though (اگرچہ), were not enough (کافی نہیں تھے). As the war dragged on, and the last oil tankers (تیل بردار جہاز) that left Hormuz at the start (آغاز) of the war reached (پہنچے) their destinations (منزلیں), the desperation (بے چینی) grew. This is where the paper oil theory (نظریہ) comes in. Oil watchers are now wondering aloud whether active oil market manipulation has begun.
If manipulation (ہیرا پھیری) is taking place (ہو رہی ہے), it means (مطلب ہے) the US government is now selling (بیچ رہی ہے) massive quantities (بڑی مقدار) of oil on the futures market, oil that they don’t actually (حقیقت میں نہیں) have, at least not at the price at which they are selling it. For the racket (غیر قانونی طریقہ) to work (چلنے کے لیے), it would need to be kept (رکھا جائے) under wraps (خفیہ), because price manipulation (قیمت میں ہیرا پھیری) in any market fails (ناکام ہوتی ہے) if players (شرکاء) know (جان لیں) that the price is being manipulated. But you know price manipulation from its effects (اثرات). In the oil markets, for instance (مثال کے طور پر), manipulation will create (پیدا کرے گی) what sector analysts (ماہرین) call (کہتے ہیں) ‘decoupling’ (الگ ہو جانا), a situation (حالت) where all the various prices that make up (تشکیل دیتے ہیں) an oil market start moving apart (الگ الگ حرکت کرنا) from each other. To some extent (حد تک), this has already happened, for example, jet fuel and diesel prices have skyrocketed (بہت بڑھ گئی ہیں) beyond (سے آگے) any of the others.
But the most important (اہم ترین) decoupling would be between the futures market and what they call the ‘physical market’ (حقیقی منڈی). The first is oil on paper (کاغذی تیل). The second is oil in hand (حقیقی تیل). Normally (عام طور پر), the price difference (فرق) between them is only a few dollars. But these days (ان دنوں), it has shot up (بہت بڑھ گیا ہے) to almost $40 per barrel (فی بیرل). And the increase (اضافہ) in this difference began shortly (جلد ہی) after March 20, when the previous (پچھلے) round (مرحلہ) of steps to stabilise oil prices were taken.
Asked about this, Terry Duffy (ٹیری ڈفی), chairman (چیئرمین) of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (شکاگو مرکنٹائل ایکسچینج), recently (حال ہی میں) said that attempts (کوششیں) to manipulate oil markets like this can create (پیدا کر سکتی ہیں) a “biblical (انتہائی بڑا) disaster (تباہی)”. Another executive (اعلیٰ عہدیدار) mentioned (ذکر کیا) to the media that his firm (کمپنی) received (موصول ہوئیں) queries (سوالات) from its clients (صارفین) on whether a recent large spurt (اچانک اضافہ) of transactions (لین دین) was initiated (شروع کیا گیا) by the US government. If done right (صحیح طریقے سے), price manipulation leaves (چھوڑتی ہے) no smoking gun evidence (واضح ثبوت) behind, because it would not work if it did. But it reveals (ظاہر کرتا ہے) itself by the effects it produces. And recent (حالیہ) moves (حرکات) in oil markets strongly (مضبوطی سے) suggest (اشارہ کرتے ہیں) that the ‘paper oil’ racket is in full swing (پورے زور پر ہے).
Khurram Husain
April 16, 2026
Dawn
Disclaimer:
The meanings of difficult words provided in this article are intended solely to help followers better understand the content. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy, any errors or misunderstandings are unintentional. If any mistake is found, we sincerely apologize and request your kind pardon.