07/09/2026
Roaming with Hounds Diary
Resource Guarding...
Yesterday I saw a post by a canine owner re their dogs behavioural change of seemingly resource guarding rest areas & humans at a specific time of day.
The comments were especially interesting... or some... well, disturbing.
Simply put, resource guarding is an animal defending a resource that has become important to its system IN RELATION to its physical and/or social system in specific contextual instances within the immediate environment. It is a survival strategy that at that instance is the most cost effective way to reduce uncertainty.
It really should not be explained with operants!!
Operants do not explain how systems are built and work. Operants predict the likelihood of interactional behaviour outputs.
If the organism would stay in a state of high environmental uncertainty, that would impose a massive metabolic and neural load; because the system has to prepare / anticipate for so many different behavioural output patterns to be ready for anything.
Controlling a resource is a survival strategy creating a more certain, predictable, contextual instance that minimizes "surprise" (free energy) with significantly lower cost.
A sudden onset of resource guarding or any form of "aggression" is rarely a new "behavioural option" the animal takes, but often a signal that the system’s ability, to predict the outcomes of its own actions in the environment, has been compromised by physical dysfunction. Protection becomes a prominent strategy.
Before applying behavioral interventions (updating priors, reducing human uncertainty), the animal, here dog, must be checked at least by a vet. Preferably though, a cooperative team of a vet or vet behaviorist, a registered animal physio and a certified dog behaviour practitioner / consultant working together with the dog and owner.
A holistic approach should include the body, sensors, proprioceptive and musculoskeletal system functions
Exteroceptive Sensors: Are the eyes, ears, or nose functioning correctly? A dog that cannot accurately perceive distance or threat (e.g., cataracts, hearing loss) may guard because their sensory input is now "noisy" and unpredictable, forcing them to cling to resources for certainty.
Proprioceptive & Musculoskeletal Systems: Pain or dysfunction in the limbs, spine, joints, soft tissue and other bodily areas alters the dog’s internal model of its own body and its ability to move safely and feel safe in relation to its environment, which includes other animals and humans.
I.e.: if a dog experiences pain when ask to move away from a resource (e.g., getting up from a bed), the cost of "leaving" becomes prohibitively high. The guarding behavior is then a physical necessity, not a choice, to regain some comfort and predictability.
Importantly!
If a dog suddenly begins guarding, a full veterinary check up is the first and non-negotiable step before any behaviour adaptation takes place, to rule out physical dysfunction: You cannot "train" away pain or sensory loss.
Evaluate the relational interactions between all beings in the immediate environment when the behaviour occurs:
Only once physical causes are ruled out or managed can we assume the guarding is driven by relational uncertainty and predictive priors, meaning memorized behaviour patterns, that the dog may have learnt to work, to "score" a resource efficiently.
Systemic Integrity: We must understand how the overall interactive network system (dog + human + environment) is built to detect the underlying causes of dysfunction.
Is the unpredictability in relation with the environment? This takes a bit of dedicated detective work.
Conclusion
Resource guarding is the path of least resistance for an organism trying to minimize uncertainty (free energy). But if the dog’s sensors are less efficient or dysfunctional, its body is in pain, the "uncertainty" is internal, not just external. We must stabilize the dog's physical system before we can hope to change behavioural interactions with professional guidance, not by taking social media or AI advice from unknown / uncertified sources.