08/11/2022
In my previous post, I made note of the fact that dominance theory has been debunked with horses. Since it's such a heavily referenced topic in how many people work with their horses (i.e., establishing a "boss" in the relationship), I think it would be helpful to expand on this a bit more.
Ethologists have observed more complicated relationships that exist within bands of feral horses; they are not as linear or simple as many of us believe them to be, nor do they display excessive amounts of aggression within their respective bands. But! We aren't dealing with feral horses, we have our good old domesticated friends - so why does it appear that most domestic herds often have very evident and straightforward hierarchies?
Resource guarding!
Unlike horses who live out in the wild with ample access to resources, many horses living under the care of humans have limited access in some way or another.
Having those limitations puts higher value on the resource itself, which gives a horse more reason to feel the need to defend it against others. This can be applied to anything that holds value to a horse, like food, shelter or water. Heck, even the human themselves can become a resource horses will covet.
As I'm sure many of us have seen, some horses are more aggressive when protecting a resource and this is what creates those bullies we see in domestic herds. In reality, when provided with adequate access to resources, you're less likely to see that aggression. Circling back to food as an example, providing multiple ad lib feeding stations throughout a paddock helps eliminate resource guarding. One hay pile (or hay net, for those who still need to control/slow down how much forage a horse is getting) per horse, plus one or two extra, ensures that there will always be at least one option available for every horse.
Management is an incredibly common issue when it comes to behaviour problems, whether that's within the herd or when working alongside us. The good news is that's usually a super easy fix!
I've attached a link to a fantastic video of Lucy Rees, an equine ethologist whose books I have found to be incredibly helpful.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mt5BG0V5jnA&ab_channel=eponatv
When scientists want to study how horses interact, they often do it by trying to figure out which horse is more aggressive and how this aggression is shown. ...